A lot of people have recommended Kee's Chocolates. But we just never checked it out until today. Kee's has a nice selection of chocolate flavors and we bought the cognac, raspberry, earl grey, kaffir lime, orange confit, coconut and green tea. It's $2.50 a piece, which is about the same price as the gourmet chocolates at Vosges and Marie Belle. I just tasted the cognac and green tea chocolates, they were really nice - not too sweet and the fillings are smooth and subtle. I can see why it's named New York's Best Chocolate by Zagat again this year.
A very "empty" Kee's Chocolates store
*pictures taken using iphone camera